The question of course, is "Who watches the Watchmen?"
I was so completely blown away by this, not just because it was a perfect adaptation, but because it was such an amazing comment on superhero movies in general. The people involved acted like ADULTS, complete with consequences for violence and people getting hot and bothered because of an adrenaline rush. Rorschach was PERFECT and even though I knew what was coming, it was still very sad when it happened. Comedian was also very much badass and felt more developed than in the comics, even though he wasn't a character you WANTED to root for or anything.
My only gripes, protected by spoiler vagueness:
- The eventual villain is pretty much telegraphed if you've read the original comics.
- Too much big blue schlong, although it was balanced out by Malin Akerman getting naked, seemingly as per her contract.
- Patrick Wilson probably should have been a bit paunchier, but he nailed the role as well.
Basically once we hit the Rorschach prison sequence my friend turned to me and said "This is EPIC!" and I'm inclined to agree. Probably won't be for all tastes, but it was definitely for mine. Highest recommendation!


