Scott,
Thanks for posting my email on TDK - have another ranking question for the blog: Where does The Dark Knight matchup as far as great movie sequels? This could be more of a list question so I might be wording this wrong. If I were to make a list of Great Franchise Sequels, I’d list them as follows in no particular -
01.) Empire Strikes Back - Star Wars Franchise
02.) Aliens - Alien Franchise
03.) Lethal Weapon 2
04.) Terminator 2
05.) The Matrix Reloaded - Matrix Franchise
06.) Spiderman 2
07.) The Two Towers - Lord of the Rings Franchise
08.) X2: XMen United
09.) The Dark Knight - Batman Franchise
10.) The Godfather II
My Top 4 would be listed as follows -
1.) Empire Strikes Back - the epitome of what a sequel should be: bigger, badder, bolder. You can tell just by how Darth Vader’s helmet glistens in ESB that Lucas said "Ok, this is what I REALLY want to do…" We were given more story and this film was carried on the back of Harrison Ford. Also, Darth Vader really underscored why he was one of Hollywood’s greatest villains. IMO, this is arguably the standard bearer that all sequels should be compared to…
2.) The Dark Knight - A fantastic crime drama. Everybody in this film hit a home run w/ their performances and I really wonder if Nolan will EVER be able to make a film better than this. The best Batman movie and the best comic book adaptation brought to cinema. *My biggest question for this email is how do you think it matches up against ESB?*
3.) Spiderman 2 - this film is what really underscored why Spidey fans love Peter Parker’s world so much: the everyday problems that we all go through and how having another responsibility can complicate life so much.
4.) The Matrix Reloaded - IMO, the best scifi action film EVER made. This movie gave me everything I wanted. W/ ESB as a template, they expanded more on the backstory of the war between humans and machines ; we saw ZION upclose and personified; and we saw some of the best fight and chase scenes that every other action/ scifi film has tried to copy in some variation; and we got a great cliffhanger ending. A true trendsetter for the early 2000’s and beyond…
That’s my list, what’s yours…
Oh man, you’re so gonna get roasted by the blog for some of that. Godfather Part II won the freakin’ OSCAR and you’d put Matrix Rebloated over it?
Speaking of the Dark Knight, rather ironic that it’s going to pass Star Wars on the all-time list the same weekend that Lucas beats at that dead house one more time with The Clone Wars.
Anyway, Godfather Part II is one of the greatest movies, of any genre, ever made and is easily my #1 pick for sequels as well. Dark Knight is all kinds of awesome, but Empire Strikes Back is still above it at #2 because there’s a reason why people say "such and such is the Empire Strikes Back of the trilogy". Then I’d put Dark Knight. And why is there never any love for James Bond? From Russia With Love completely defined the Bond franchise and added all the elements that came to be associated with the character from then on.